Rock & Roll Bookend

I wish I always could be so lucky: this past week I started and ended it at a concert. On Monday, I saw the Foo Fighters play an acoustic show at the Beacon Theatre (Frank Black - Pixies - opened). Last night, I saw Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young (CSNY) perform at the Theatre at MSG after two different people in my life, separated age-wise by over 20 years, both raved about their performance on this tour. While I immensely enjoyed both shows, I was struck by the amazing emotional gulf between the two, mostly in terms of relevancy and importance. One was simply music - the other was music and so much more.

The Foo show was great and left me all smiles. Dave Grohl was engaging, a regular chatty Kathy actually, and their expanded roster of musicians (Pat Smear was back w/ them - gotta love a punk rock dude who was in a band called the Germs whose name rhymes with pap smear) played a lot of the new tracks off of the acoustic side of their new record along with a good number of older songs - "Its all about the catalog dude!" Dave yelled at one point. The songs were all really well done but one song sticks out in particular after last night's show: "In Your Honor," the title track from their latest album. Dave wrote that in honor of John Kerry while he was out on the campaign trail with him. He sung it well and the band rocked it out but he never mentioned the campaign, the current world we live in, Bush or anything political at all. He simply played the tune and moved on to other tunes, like "Everlong." Looking back, it was like listening to rock & roll cotton candy - all fluff and no substance.

Comparabily, the CSNY show didn't feed you at all: it threw a bucket of cold water in your face and let you know that shits all sorts of fucked up and then worked up your appetite to do something about it. I thought that CSNY would stick to a "safe" show of their classic hits but instead they grabbed the show by the balls. In a surprise, the group played a ton of songs off of Neil Young's new album Living With War which completely slams the Imperial Bush Presidency and the GWOT (global war on terror for those not up on the lingo). I urged you months ago to listen to the Neil's new disc and I urge you again now. The group displayed on a huge video screen US deaths broken out by month and lambasted the president for not attending a single soldier's funeral. They showed a picture of every single dead soldier thus far - 2,607 of them (a fact I know because of last night's show) - while they played a song dedicated to the troops. They put the words to the new Neil Young song "Let's Impeach the President" on screen and urged the crowd to sing along. They played "Teach Your Children" and Crosby said "Every teacher's salary should be tripled!" before launching into it. They played "Ohio" and as everyone was singing "4 dead in Ohio" it felt in a way like Kent State could have just happened.

My friend and I over and over again just couldn't believe that it was 2006, almost 40 years after these gents made their debut, and that we were watching these 4 strong, clear voices belt out songs with such meaning, harmony and clarity, that we were watcing their fingers run wild and pluck out tunes that scarily matter more than ever. Their stamina too must be commended - they played for a total of 3 hours (with only a 20 min break in the middle so the show was almost 3.5 hrs long). Their message of peace is still a sound one. The peace symbol on the stage wasn't a dated relic of the 60's. It was a stark reminder that the more things change, the more they stay the same. There is a battle for peace too and that battle needs to be fought and not ignored.

Sitting around reflecting this morning, I wish every concert now packed the same emotional punch that the CSNY show did. Art for art's sake in a world gone crazy sometimes is not enough. Someone has to be out there making art with a purpose, art with a message. It was like watching Lou Reed's perfomance at the Hurricane Katrina Summerstage benefit for 3 hours. I feel blessed, energized and motivated. Maybe if every show packed this type of punch I would feel battered but a good slap in the face once in a while to me is a good thing.